The evaluation and adoption of decumulation strategies that address the retirement income dilemma has become a priority for many defined contribution (DC) plan sponsors. However, they have been hesitant to adopt untested solutions. It is no surprise, then, that more than 25,000 DC plans have added PIMCO Income Fund to their plan menus.1 For more than a decade, the fund has sought to deliver maximum current income and long-term capital appreciation. In the following Q&A, Rick Fulford, head of U.S. defined contribution, and Esteban Burbano, fixed income strategist, explain how PIMCO Income Fund seeks to serve the retirement income needs of defined contribution retirees.
Q: WHAT OPTIONS DO RETIREES HAVE FOR SEEKING TO GENERATE INCOME IN RETIREMENT?
Fulford: Most baby boomers rely upon several sources of income in retirement, including Social Security, financial assets (whether from a DC plan or IRA) and defined benefit pensions. However the relative importance of these sources is shifting, with greater emphasis being placed on one’s financial assets.
Social Security remains an essential source of retirement income for most Americans. In many respects, it’s a perfect solution. It hedges both inflation and longevity risks, providing an inflation-adjusted income stream for life.
However, for the average participant, it’s simply not enough. According to the Social Security Administration, Social Security benefits will satisfy only 40% of the average wage earner’s income after retiring – in large measure because the program was designed as a social safety net, not a holistic retirement income solution. In addition, only about 15% of baby boomers have access to a traditional pension benefit. By contrast, 55% have access to a DC plan.2
Therefore, most Americans will come to rely more heavily on financial assets held within their DC plan or IRA for generating income in retirement.
Q: BASED UPON OBSERVED BEHAVIOR, WHAT TYPES OF RETIREMENT INCOME SOLUTIONS DO RETIREES WANT?
Fulford: Retirees value straightforward solutions that seek to generate consistent income and preserve account balances. The preference for income stems from the desire to replace the “paycheck” earned during one’s working years. The preference to preserve account balances reflects the increase in risk aversion one experiences at retirement, driven by the loss of a steady income stream and uncertainty related to one’s future spending needs.
These entirely rational preferences are consistent with an Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI)³ study that shows retirees spend largely from income alone and only modestly draw down account balances during their retirement years. Clearly, retirees appear to be following a conservative approach that helps to mitigate longevity risk – the risk of outliving one’s assets.
In addition, retirees place high value on solutions that emphasize liquidity, allowing for control over capital and spending. According to the most recent study from the EBRI, at a ratio of 5 to 1 retirees prefer retirement income solutions that emphasize access and control over those that sacrifice flexibility in exchange for income guarantees, even if it means giving up guarantees.
Why is this? Most retirees are not well-equipped to forecast the makeup and magnitude of their future consumption needs and therefore prefer solutions that allow them to adapt to their evolving situation.
This, in addition to behavioral biases, largely explains the limited retiree adoption of guaranteed solutions, specifically immediate and deferred income annuities, within DC plans.
Taking into account these behavioral preferences, an attractive retirement income solution should target a consistent income stream, aim to protect capital, and provide liquidity.
Q: WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR PLAN SPONSORS DEVELOPING A RETIREMENT INCOME TIER? SHOULD THEY SEEK AN ALL-IN-ONE INCOME SOLUTION OR MULTIPLE SOLUTIONS?
Fulford: Many plan sponsors are considering adding multiple strategies to their retirement tier – some focused on single asset classes, others that combine multiple asset classes. This could be sensible, as retirees, who tend to be the most engaged participants within a DC plan, prefer to select their portfolios and will likely value some degree of choice in seeking to satisfy their particular needs.4
According to Cerulli Associates, plan sponsors consider a fairly wide set of solutions for delivering retirement income, but focus on fixed income more than any other asset class, followed by target-date funds. In contrast, few plan sponsors consider retirement income solutions that offer annuity-based guarantees (see Figure 1).
The focus on bonds is understandable because a highly diversified, high-yielding multi-sector bond portfolio can provide many of the key characteristics that participants desire – including the potential for investment income, modest growth potential and capital preservation.
Q: HOW COULD PIMCO INCOME FUND WORK AS PART OF A RETIREMENT INCOME SOLUTION?
Burbano: While the industry is hard at work developing multiple retirement income solutions, adoption of such strategies may still be years away. After all, implementation will require market education, plan sponsor diligence, and successful track records over three to five years.
PIMCO Income Fund is an income-focused multi-sector bond strategy that could be a solution for plan sponsors seeking to implement a retirement tier. It solves for many of the needs expressed by DC participants in retirement:
- It’s straightforward: The Income Fund is a straightforward strategy that is simple for plan sponsors to implement and is easily communicated to participants.
- It seeks to provide maximum current income: The fund has delivered consistent monthly distributions over the past 12 years.5
- It seeks to preserve capital: The fund has an emphasis on capital preservation and seeks long-term capital appreciation as a secondary objective.
- It’s been widely adopted by plan sponsors: The Income Fund is now offered in more than 25,000 defined contribution plan menus, up from 4,000 just five years ago.6
Q: HOW HAS PIMCO INCOME FUND PERFORMED AS A POTENTIAL RETIREMENT INCOME SOLUTION?
Burbano: Over most time periods, PIMCO Income Fund has delivered outcomes important to retirees, including 1) strong total returns, 2) consistent income, and 3) capital preservation.7 In addition, for a hypothetical retiree following the 4% consumption rule (spending 4% of their starting wealth adjusted for inflation each year), PIMCO Income Fund has delivered a consistent income distribution (see Figure 2), which would have been able to satisfy the retiree’s monthly consumption needs entirely through income, without drawing down principal.
Q: CAN YOU DESCRIBE IN A BIT MORE DETAIL THE STRATEGY THAT UNDERLIES PIMCO INCOME FUND?
Burbano: PIMCO Income Fund is managed with two key objectives in mind: maximizing current income and long-term capital appreciation. We take a long-term view, and use a balanced approach in seeking to meet these objectives across different market environments. We allocate across higher-yielding assets that tend to do well in positive economic scenarios, and high quality assets that tend to help mitigate the downside in risk-off scenarios.
PIMCO Income Fund invests globally and across sectors, and has the flexibility to manage the two key risks that typically exist in a bond portfolio – duration risk and credit risk – all while seeking to deliver maximum current income. The fund manages duration actively, which has helped it to navigate challenging interest rate markets over the past 10 years. It has sought to diversify credit risk via broad exposures, aiming to enhance value and preserve capital in periods of market stress.
We draw on the full breadth of PIMCO’s resources – including more than 255 portfolio managers and over 65 analysts as of 20 June 2019, who cover various sectors of the fixed income markets from offices around the world. These teams of specialists are continuously sourcing the best ideas from every sector and feeding recommendations to the Income Fund’s lead portfolio managers.
This structure allows the Income Fund to implement ideas from different sectors and regions in an effort to build a portfolio that targets an attractive yield while mitigating downside risk.
For the most recent quarter-end performance data for PIMCO Income Fund, please click on the link below:
Click for the "Income Fund summary prospectus."
Read more about PIMCO income strategies here.