Trying to Make Apple Juice From Oranges: The Problem With Comparing Market Pricing and Fed Projections
While the U.S. Federal Reserve (Fed) appears to be nearing a point where it considers pausing its interest rate hiking cycle, market participants are already pricing in the timing and magnitude of future rate cuts. Specifically, the market appears to be pricing in cuts to the Fed’s short-term policy rate starting in the second half of this year and continuing into 2024 and beyond, with tradable forward rates going from just under 5% by mid-2023 to about 3% in only 18 months’ time.
This pricing is garnering attention from market participants and pundits alike, fostering a debate about what type of economic outcome – namely a hard or soft landing – the market is pricing in. The resulting assumptions can feed into the pricing of different asset classes, creating significant implications for investors.
So what to make of the discrepancy between forwards, one of the most closely watched market rates that price in future interest rate expectations, and the Fed’s own projections (see Figure 1)? Does the market really disagree with the Fed by more than a full percentage point when it comes to where rates will be next year?
We’d like to caution against the false sense of precision that market-based rates can provide, and to suggest that the answer is much more nuanced. Notably, a forward rate should not be viewed as a standalone expectation of where short-term rates will be. Rather, it is probability-weighted.
Dots vs. markets
Each quarter, the Fed’s policy-setting committee publishes a chart, known as the dot plot, summarizing individual members’ projections for the federal funds rate. Each dot distills one member’s range of possibilities into a single, most likely point. However, each dot does nothing to illustrate that member’s entire possible range of outcomes, therefore conveying a higher level of confidence in any given point.
The closely watched median dot, which plots at 4.125% for year-end 2024 as of the most recent chart released in December, represents the median point of all members’ projections – each of which, again, is a distilled representation of a range of most likely outcomes.
The median is expressed as a single figure, yet the range of individual members’ dots for year-end 2024 spans 2.625 percentage points, from 3% to 5.625%. This range is important, as it shows substantial uncertainty even within the Fed itself. This uncertainty should also be taken into consideration when considering market pricing.
Looking strictly at forward rates can give an oversimplified view, whereby the market is or is not pricing this or that outcome. This can be shortsighted, as the market is made up of countless participants, each with a unique view on a potential range of outcomes. A forward rate is not necessarily the market’s singular expectation of the future, but rather a rate derived from a range of probability-weighted outcomes.
One could look at current market pricing and determine that the Fed is going to raise rates to about 4.9% by mid-year 2023 and then cut by about 200 basis points (bps), or two full percentage points, in the subsequent 18 months, based on what the probability-weighted averages show.
We think that is a narrow interpretation of what the market is displaying. Solely looking at the forward points offers no information about the distribution and market confidence around those points.
Options and distributions
Extending the market pricing inputs to include options prices can paint a more robust picture of what the market is truly expecting. Figure 2 uses CME-listed options on three-month Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) futures contracts to build a distribution map of outcomes.
This isn’t a perfect comparison, given SOFR is not the same as the fed funds rate – it’s a three-month borrowing gauge rather than a six-week measure, and futures (and options on futures) liquidity isn’t as deep as it has been in the past. Yet it can still provide valuable insight into the market’s confidence around the forward points, as the use of SOFR options offers more reliable pricing, while options on fed funds futures have negligible volume and open interest.
We find two initial main takeaways from this distribution map:
- The market is displaying a fair amount of confidence that the Fed won’t spend a significant amount of time holding rates above 5%, if at all – in fact, the market is pricing about a 70% chance that the policy rate is below the Fed’s median projection of 4.125% by year-end 2024.
- The range of likely and even possible outcomes drifts meaningfully wider as you get into 2024 and beyond.
As investors perceive that the Fed is approaching a peak in its policy rate, it is typical for the market to start pricing in subsequent rate cuts. The pricing of the severity and timing of those cuts will evolve with incoming data.
In determining the market’s expectations, we think it’s prudent to look beyond just the forward rates. Although forward rates are actively tradable, they alone don’t paint the full picture of market expectations. Understanding the uncertainty around specific forward points can help frame a more robust narrative.
Mike Cudzil is a generalist portfolio manager and Tim Crowley is a portfolio manager on the U.S. rates desk, both in the Newport Beach office.
PIMCO as a general matter provides services to qualified institutions, financial intermediaries and institutional investors. Individual investors should contact their own financial professional to determine the most appropriate investment options for their financial situation. This material contains the opinions of the manager and such opinions are subject to change without notice. This material has been distributed for informational purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed. No part of this material may be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without express written permission. PIMCO is a trademark of Allianz Asset Management of America LLC in the United States and throughout the world. ©2023, PIMCO.
Tell us a little about you to help us personalize the site to your needs.
Select Your Location
Europe, Middle East & Africa
Location not listed? Visit our Global Site.
Terms and Conditions
Please read and acknowledge the following terms and conditions
This website is for the exclusive use of qualified investors as defined by the Swiss Collective Investment Schemes Act of 23 June 2006 (“CISA”) as well as of quasi-institutional non-qualified investors.
By clicking ‘Accept’, I acknowledge and agree to the terms and conditions above. I undertake to access the information contained in this web site for my personal use and not for commercial use. I confirm that I am a qualified investor as defined by the CISA, respectively a quasi-institutional non-qualified investor, but not a retail investor.
LEGAL INFORMATION FOR INVESTORS OF Switzerland
By accessing this website and the products, services, information, tools and materials that it contains or describes, you acknowledge that you have understood and accept the following terms and conditions of use. Please read these terms and conditions of use carefully before using this website. PIMCO (Schweiz) GmbH, Brandschenkestrasse 41, 8002 Zürich, is responsible for the activities carried out through this website. You may use the materials on this website solely for personal, informational and noncommercial purposes. All rights not expressly granted in these terms and conditions of use are reserved by PIMCO.
This website only includes information on the PIMCO Global Investors Series plc funds and , PIMCO ETFs plc funds which are currently registered with FINMA for offer to non-qualified investors in Switzerland (the “PIMCO Funds”). It is your responsibility to be aware of and to observe all applicable laws and regulations of any relevant jurisdiction. The prospectus and key investor information documents (KIIDs), the articles of association as well as the annual and semi-annual reports may be obtained free of charge from the representative in Switzerland. Swiss representative and paying agent is BNP Paribas Securities Services, Paris, succursale de Zurich, Selnaustrasse 16, 8002 Zurich, Switzerland. The Fund's country of origin is Ireland.
The information contained in this website constitutes an advertisement within the meaning of Article 68 of the Swiss Financial Services Act ("FinSA") for the PIMCO Funds.
INFORMATION ON FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
The information contained in this website is not intended as an offer to sell securities or a solicitation to buy PIMCO Funds. The goal is to provide general information on PIMCO Funds that have been authorised for sale in Switzerland and are available for investment and purchase in Switzerland. This site is not directed to individuals or organizations for whom such offer or invitation would be unlawful or prohibited.
PIMCO Europe Ltd, its subsidiaries, affiliates or subsidiaries, including PIMCO (Schweiz) GmbH (hereinafter collectively "PIMCO") assume no responsibility for the financial or other consequences arising from the subscription or purchase of the securities described in this website.
The information presented in this website is based, among other things, on market data at a given time, that is therefore subject to market changes and may change from time to time. Although the information contained in this website is from sources deemed reliable, no guarantee is made as to its accuracy, completeness or reliability. No warranty or representation is made in respect to the information contained in this website including without limit that the information is accurate, complete or timely, except for information concerning PIMCO Funds. PIMCO only warrants that the information contained and opinions expressed in this website are accurate at the date of publication. The price of shares of the PIMCO Funds contained in this website is indicative only and should not be relied upon for dealing purposes.
Users should ensure that they are legally allowed access to this website in the country from which they connect.
You must read the relevant prospectus for the Global Investors Series Plc ("GIS") for all the relevant risk factors pertaining to each sub-fund.
Investment in collective investment in transferable securities involves risks. Performance is shown gross of withholding tax. The source of performance data is PIMCO. Past performance is no guarantee for future results.
INFORMATION ON FINANCIAL SERVICES
The information contained in this website may constitute a purchase or sale of financial instruments within the meaning of Article 3 let. c ch.1 FinSA, triggering the FinSA rules of conduct. PIMCO is however not required to assess the appropriateness and suitability in accordance with FinSA as it does not give investment advice.
No investment advice, tax advice, or legal advice is provided through this website, and you agree that this website will not be used by you for these purposes. No representation is given that shares, products, or services identified on or accessible through, this website are suitable for any particular investor. You acknowledge that your use of this website and any requests for information are unsolicited.
The information on this website does not constitute an offer or a solicitation, or a recommendation to implement or liquidate an investment or to carry out any other transaction. It should not be used as a basis for any investment decision or other decision. Any investment decision should be based on appropriate professional advice specific to your needs.
GENERAL RISK FACTORS
Past performance is no guide to or guarantee for future returns. Please note that the price of shares and the income from them can fall as well as rise and you may not get back the amount originally invested. Income receivable may vary from the amount of income projected at the time of making the investment.
For a complete list of risk factors, you should refer to the prospectus of the relevant PIMCO Funds.
For details of how we might collect and use your personal data collected through our website, please see our Privacy Notice.
RECORD OF CALLS
For your safety and ours, conversations with the staff of PIMCO may be recorded. In case of dispute related to these conversations, records of phone calls can be admitted as evidence in court or other legal process to the extent permitted by applicable law.
LINKS TO AND FROM OTHER SITES
PIMCO is not responsible for hypertext links to other sites, in particular as regards the content of these sites, advice and information provided by the authors of these sites for the subscription or redemption of securities, or in respect of subscriptions and redemptions of securities through such third party sites.
PIMCO is not responsible for hypertext links to this site. The creation of such links is prohibited without the prior express permission of PIMCO.
LIMITATION OF LIABILITY
YOU EXPRESSLY UNDERSTAND AND AGREE THAT YOUR USE OF THIS WEBSITE IS AT YOUR SOLE RISK AND THAT THE WEBSITE IS PROVIDED ON AN "AS IS" AND "AS AVAILABLE" BASIS AND WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR REPRESENTATIONS OF ANY KIND EITHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED. TO THE FULL EXTENT PERMITTED UNDER APPLICABLE LAW, PIMCO EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, WHETHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, AND NON-INFRINGEMENT.
PIMCO makes no warranty or representation that this website can be accessed at all times. This website may, without notice, be temporarily unavailable or restricted for administrative or other reasons.
You will indemnify PIMCO (including their affiliated or associated companies) and their officers, directors, employees and agents in respect of any third-party claim for any injury, loss, damage or expense occasioned by or arising directly or indirectly from your operation or use of this website or your supply of information to a third party provided in breach of any of your obligations under these terms and conditions of use.
This website is not designed for the transmission of time sensitive instructions or questions. If you transmit any communication through this website to PIMCO directly or through any third-party internet or other service provider, you shall be responsible and liable for any omissions or failures that may be made while transmitting or receiving communications using this website. Furthermore, if you use this website to transmit time sensitive instructions or questions, you will be liable for any loss that may arise, and any such information is transmitted at your own risk.